Student Debate: Paris Congestion Zone: Monday 12 November 2012

Central London's Congestion Charge Zone

Since 2003 the City of London has had a novel program to reduce automobile congestion in the center of the city. 

London congestion charge is a fee charged on most motor vehicles operating in central London between 07:00 and 18:00 (Monday-Friday only).  The zone is the largest congestion zones in the world

• Standard charge is £10 per day
• Reduced rates for many classes of travelers
• Penalty of £60 to £187 levied for non-payment.
• Enforced with automatic number plate recognition

London Impacts

• Traffic - The number vehicles in Central London reduced by 30% (primarily cars) with increases in the numbers of taxis, buses, and especially bicycles. (2007)
• Traffic Speeds - Up 30% (2007)
• Road Safety - 40 to 70 fewer automobile injuries per year
• Air Quality - No measureable impact. “It is difficult to identify significant air quality improvements from a specific program—especially one targeted at a small area within a large city—against broader regional pollution and weather changes.“
• Click here for more information

Debate Proposition

In order to reduce traffic congestion, improve quality of life, encourage more sustainable transport and improve safety,  the City of Paris should implement a Congestion Charge Zone covering Arrondissenments 1 through 8.

For the affirmative:

Romain, Slyvain, Alexandra, Antonio

For the negative

Nordine, Roland, Mockhorty